If you smash your fist into someone’s body are you being aggressive and anti-social, or are you just doing what your genes programme you to do? The idea of genes affecting behaviour isn’t new and isn’t disputed, but the use of certain genes as a mitigating factor in criminal behaviour is a contentious issue. Genes have been used as part of the defence in cases of murder, and moral and ethical arguments around this use have focused on the low validity of the research evidence plus the generally accepted concepts of free will and personal responsibility. The argument has been taken a stage further now as a convicted murderer in Italy has had his sentence reduced partly because of his history of psychiatric illness and also partly because his genome includes five genes known to be associated with violent behaviour. One of these genes is a variant of MAOA, which codes for an enzyme which breaks down amines in the brain, and this low-activity variant correlates in research findings with violence and aggression, giving it its nickname the “warrior” gene. However, as we all know, correlations are not necessarily causal; and then there is the responsibility debate. So, what would you decide if you were on the jury, the defendant was clearly guilty of murder, but also had a gene profile predisposing him or her to violence and aggression?
A Level
A Level Psychology
Anne Watson
assessment
authors
Back to school
Ben Crystal
book list
book recommendations
brain
children's authors
children's books
children's dictionaries
children's fiction
classroom
comprehension
concepts/language
confirmation bias
COVID-19
CPD
critical thinking
curriculum
david crystal
definitions
depression
Dictionaries
dictionary
Digital
drama
ed-tech
Education
english
English Literature
ethics
exams
false friends
funny books
GCSE
guided reading
history
History teacher
home learning
implications
independent reading
Jill Carter
knowledge questions
KS1
KS2
KS3
language
learning
literacy
literature
Mastery
mathematics
maths
maths mastery
media
memory
methodology
MFL
natural sciences
non-fiction
Ofsted
perspectives
Phonics
post-sats
primary
psychology
reading
reading for pleasure
reading list
Rebecca Priest
remote learning
research
revision
Sam Holyman
SATs
science
secondary
secondary education
shakespeare
Shakespeare400
shared knowledge
teaching
teaching ideas
technology
TOK emotion
TOK intuition
TOK language
TOK reason
TOK sense perception
truth
Vocabulary
vocabulary building
wellbeing
Word Gap
words
world book day
writing